« Why Come to New Attitude? | Main | Dull Moments and Homeschool Curriculum »

Mommy's Got a Brand New Belly

my-beautiful-mommy.jpg

I thought this was pretty incredible: Newsweek features excerpts from a children's book about cosmetic surgery. They write:

Tapping into what may be a growing market, a plastic surgeon has written and published a book for the children of women who have cosmetic surgery procedures like breast implants, tummy tucks and nose jobs. 'My Beautiful Mommy' by Dr. Michael Salzhauer aims to reassure kids that Mom's bruises and bandages are just temporary, and that the new, improved mommy won't be different, just 'prettier.'
And the Associated Press tells how the idea for the book came about:

Dr. Michael Salzhauer said so many moms brought kids to their appointments that he was motivated to stock up on lollipops in his Bal Harbour, Fla., office. In "My Beautiful Mommy," he explains mommy's recuperation, changing look and desire for plastic surgery.


"Many parents don't explain to their kids what's going on," said the father of four, with his fifth child on the way. "Children are very perceptive. You can't hide a major surgery from them. When mom goes down for two weeks after a tummy tuck it affects them."

Illustrations show a crook-nosed mom with loose tummy skin under her half shirt picking up her young daughter early from school one day and taking her to a strapping and handsome "Dr. Michael."

Mom explains she's going to have operations on her nose and tummy and may have to take it easy for a week or so. The girl asks if the operations will hurt, and mom replies, "Maybe a little," warning she'll look different after the bandages come off.

The girl asks: "Why are you going to look different?"

Mom responds: "Not just different, my dear -- prettier!"

A couple of thoughts: first, can you imagine if Dr. Seuss had done a book based on this concept? I will refrain from any rhymes at this point.

Second, and this is obvious, but a book like this points to the fact that cosmetic surgery is fast becoming the modern day equivalent of getting your hair colored. (Will do-it-yourself kits that come in a box at the grocery store soon follow?)

And third, if kids have this kind of bedtime reading, is there any doubt that cosmetic surgery will only become more and more "normal" in the future?

Reading about this book brings to mind is the importance of training our children, especially our giris, to think about beauty and their bodies from a biblical perspective. How can we teach them that prettier doesn't equal happier? We need to take steps to show them that godly character and the fear of God are more to be desired than the perfect nose or body. We need to teach from a young age the truth of Proverbs 11:22 that says, "Like a gold ring in a pig's snout is a beautiful woman without discretion" (ESV). This is true even if the pig has had a "snout job."

My friend Nicole Whitacre writes some insightful thoughts on this subject:

Because of the gospel, we can be free from this fruitless and rebellious search to find satisfaction in receiving admiration for our physical beauty. We can live for Christ instead. And thus our hearts can "be fixed, where true joys are to be found" (Book of Common Prayer, 1662).

So what difference should the gospel make in how we think about beauty today?

First, instead of complaining to the mirror about our imperfect body, let's consider how we can live for Christ by trusting Him and serving others. True joy will inevitably follow.

And secondly, if we're tempted to envy (or self-righteously judge) the beautiful, immodestly dressed co-worker, classmate, or fellow mom, for the attention they receive, let's pray for them instead--that they too would find true joy in Christ.

Moms and daughters can also find valuable guidance in the book Girltalk: Mother to Daughter Conversations on Biblical Womanhood written by Nicole and her mom, Carolyn Mahaney. (Parents of girls, I'd love to hear steps you've taken to pass on a right perspective toward beauty to your daughters. Please leave a comment.)

One final thought: because of the prevalence of plastic surgery I think that Christians need to think carefully about how we talk about this issue. Right now I think many Christians speak very disparagingly, even scornfully about it (okay, at least I know I'm guilty of doing this). But I realize that an offhand, scornful remark could be deeply hurtful to people who I might not know have had a procedure done. So while I think that critiquing and resisting the appearance obsession of our age is good, we also need to make sure that we're being loving toward people around us. They're trusting in the false hope that a better body is going to fulfill them. They need the liberating power of the gospel. And if we ever want to have the chance to share the hope of the gospel with them we should be careful about how we speak about plastic surgery.

Comments (18)

Oh...I thought this was going to be a post announcing Shannan is pregnant again. So no babies on the horizon?

That's just crazy. So many things are becoming the norm that I'm dreading the day that I have kids and have to teach them the way of the Lord amidst all the worldly ideas and general social consensus. It irks me so when people go after kids to push their ideas forward. Sounds like they just want to secure future patients.

Gospel is spelled wrong in the second to last sentence...

What an interesting and thought-provoking post.

The subject of physical beauty is a loaded one, to say the least. Especially as Christians I think we struggle with how to handle all the facets and questions that crop up when we deal with the age-old debate about how much our outer man matters.

Perhaps we all can agree that Scripture is clear that God finds delight in beauty of all kinds. He ought to, it's His. But one kind of beauty shines for Him above all. And that is the beauty of the inner man. Outer beauty is a gift, a gift that the Bible says will one day, despite all our attempts to stall the inevitable, fail. We will get wrinkly, we will sag, we will become very, very 'real'. Not unlike the velveteen rabbit.

I will freely admit that the book pictures in the above post made me giggle (I died when I saw the 'Dr.' in the tight, blue muscle shirt...that is so funny.) However, I loved how the writer (I'm not sure if it was Josh or Shannon) brought it home to roost when they commented about our need to look past the outside to the inward man. A spirit that God thinks is beautiful. It's more than merely rearranging our priorities. It's deeper than that. I believe it has to do with the simple but profound act of taking God at His word. Do we truly believe, ladies and gentlemen, that He looks at our heart? Really? Do we believe it? I think we tend to be a generation that thinks God is somehow blind. So we have become content with whatever darkness is lurking in our hearts, while piling on the cosmetics, somehow hoping it will make up for the deficit.

God, thankfully, is not fooled. He is faithful to continue that holy purging and purifying that produces the purest of beauty, the kind that won't get old or sag or need the attentions of a hunky doctor in a turquoise, blue muscle shirt.*grin*

And, as God teaches us to see through His lens of beauty, let's pray for the kind of eyes that see beyond either the saggy, old kind of exterior, or the 'pretty new mommy' kind, and with the power and love that only the Holy Spirit can give, let's get close enough to the people around us to see the heart.

That is what He's after, folks. Let's be ambassadors for true beauty.

I thought Shannon was pregnant, too! Real funny -- NOT! Seriously, though, I feel like I was tricked into reading about this insane book. =)
True Christians seriously need to write some children's books. We wonder why my generation is so weird and doing crazy stuff, but if you look at the children's and teen's section of a bookstore it's pretty obvious. We become what we eat -- in heart and soul. Just think what could be if only Christians had and used the zeal to influence kids that people like Madonna and J. K. Rowling or this author put into action...

As I read your post, I would be careful about this issue.

I believe that scripture does teach that inner beauty is more important than outer beauty.

And I think it is very important to teach the next generation of girls about the importance of character and godly beauty.

However, I don't think it is right to say plastic surgery in it of itself is something wrong or sinful. I think girls will always struggle with their personal appearance whether it's about how much they weight or about makeup, etc.

So I think it's good we are talking about this, and sharing godly principles, but I would be careful that we dont't put our own personal standards about what we think girls can or can't do.

This article hits home for me because, although I do not yet have children, I am an adult daughter of a woman with serious body image problems. Although my mother has not undergone plastic surgery, she is constantly referencing it, almost threatening to have some kind of procedure done. My mom is gorgeous; sure, she's had 3 kids, she's not "young" any more, doesn't have the same body she had at 20, etc. But she is one of the most beautiful women I know. It doesn't matter how many times my dad or anyone else tells her how beautiful she is, she never accepts it. She is constantly battling insecurity and comparing herself to other women, and accusing my dad of not being attracted to her (which is totally not true). This has had a huge impact on our family. Now in my early 20s, I feel the ramifications of an attitude I heard all my life from my mother. I also have a 14 year old sister who is constantly bombarded with this. By God's grace, I have battled this mindset that has been instilled in me. Does anyone have any advice on how to deal with this as a daughter? How can I encourage my mom to find her security in Christ and quit focusing on herself so much (she is a believer and a pastor's wife nonetheless)? Also, how can I encourage my younger sister who still lives at home to deal with this? And to any woman reading this with daughters, please recognize that your attitudes and words about your own beauty or lack thereof are of huge significance to your daughters - we listen and emulate - you are our standard of what a woman should be.

Just so everyone knows, the idea that the title of this post might imply that Shannon was pregnant never even crossed my mind! So I didn't mean to do a "bait and switch." I hope all the women will forgive me.

Joshua Harris

As a committed Christian mom of young girls, I strive to continually emphasize to them the greater importance of character and countenance ("Honey, that angry face makes that dress look a lot less pretty!"). But I'm also a committed Christian wife who recently had plastic surgery, and so I wonder if I might share another persepective? The nature of the topic makes it difficult to be delicate/modest or brief, but hopefully this will be appropriate.

I find it interesting that while the Bible appears to elevate the symbolic value of grey hair, the majority of Christian women appear to reject that sentiment with great passion. :) Conversely, both Proverbs and especially Song of Solomon are very specific in their celebration of the right appreciation of physical beauty, and yet any woman who decides to quietly have her body temporarily restored after multiple children to please her husband must have inherently wrong motives (or he does!). It seems that the Church's response to the world's corruption of a good thing sometimes is as extreme as its response in centuries past to things like books or theater or music. Because the world corrupts these aspects of our culture and all too often uses them to celebrate evil, all use of them is evil. In the realm of plastic surgery as a way to improve appearance, because every form of media flaunts both the process and the results in the crassest and most debased possible way, then any Christian who chooses this approach must also have the same motives and desires. Yes, there are issues of physical risk and expense, but there are those same issues with things like expensive vacations to exotic locations, buying a brand new car that instantly depreciates in value, or leisure activities like bungee jumping or racing cars, or getting a tattoo.

My desire was simply to have my body restored so that I would no longer need to use all the other artificial means I had been to hide my issues from the general public, but that my husband saw every day. I wanted to reverse that - to preserve and keep the most significant display of my outward self for my husband. I also wanted to honor my husband's continuing commitment to pursuing purity in his life. He works defensively by keeping his eyes from impure images; I wanted to work offensively by caring for my appearance and body. I exercise regularly, eat healthfully, but the process of childbearing left me with significant things that those methods would never help.

In having my procedures done (by a surgeon who is as highly respected for his committed Christian faith as he is for his skill), instead of being less modest, I am more so - the very fact that I am more proportioned actually motivates me to keep msyelf dressed appropriately in public (and in private. :)) I spend less time in front of mirroors instead of more. My husband, who delighted in me before, delights in me now. Is he more delighted in my heart and love for the Lord? Absolutely.

This is indeed a complicated topic. But just as the Christian who works in Hollywood informed my perspective on American Idol "hijacking" worship music, I hope these thoughts provide another perspective. In no way am I saying that all Christian women should do this. But I am inviting the Body to be as grace-filled in this area as we are in others, and be willing to consider that not all motives in this are wrong.

And for the record, yes, I'd put the idea of a kids' book on the subject in the category of crass and unnecessary!

Oh, I was totally kidding about being tricked into reading this! I thought it was funny how it came across and actually joked about it because it seemed pretty unintentional. Thanks for the concern and effort to clarify for all of us, though. It is pretty funny -- of all the titles you could choose! Why, Josh... why?! (I'm just kidding.)

For the other Josh; I actually learned something on this subject recently from (surprise, surprise!) Hudson Taylor. He was talking in a sermon about the Bride of Christ and the beautiful allegory of Song of Songs. In the beginning of the book, the Bride thinks she's not all that great looking -- she's got blemishes, she's been out in the sun way too long... Even though tan is in, I think most girls can relate pretty well to what she's saying. But then later in the book we see that not only does God call her beautiful in many ways, but she actually becomes very beautiful and even reflects His Beauty. How does that happen? Hint: No spas are involved, no gyms, no plastic surgery; but it does involve a lot of diligent discipline on our part -- as the Bride. Hudson Taylor describes it as us being like a mirror. If we look at the things of the world and ourselves, it's not gonna be pretty -- what we reflect. We're going to be full of blemishes, full of sin, etc. But if we turn and look at Him, we will reflect Him -- and that's what people will see when they look at us. We'll show forth His Beauty in ways this world can see. So, basically, I guess my tip on this topic is: Stop looking in mirrors so much -- focusing on the things of this world or yourself. Start being a mirror -- a reflection of God's Beauty. For no beauty can compare or compete or add to His. Be a bearer of beauty in this world by telling them that with all that you are and all that you do.
Do this and I promise you you'll love and know and recognize (not to mention, offer the world) real, incredible, breath-taking, beautiful Beauty. And you'll begin to see and appreciate the beauty (or even just the potential for beauty -- if that's all there is so far) in every person.
It's kind of like in Psalms when David talks about God's Law being finer to him than pure gold. We all think that sounds nice and like an admirable thing to say, but do we feel the same? I didn't for a long while. But I wanted to, and I knew I wanted to be the right kind of rich, so I asked God to do whatever it takes to make me that way. Now I read those verses and they are totally different to me -- I don't just think they sound nice, but instead, I know them to be true and I agree with them with my whole heart, mind, soul and spirit. Before, riches sounded nice... earthly ones... but I'd easily trade them for other things once I got them -- I know it. But now that I know and have the true Riches of His Justice and Law and Truth and Word within my heart, I could never, would never, trade them for ANYTHING.
I promise you that if you obtain and truly come to fully know true Beauty, you'll know what I mean and feel the same.
God bless.

Ann,

I appreciate you sharing your perspective. While different people will differ on this issue it's obvious that you're seeking to be guided by biblical values.

I wish you and your family all the best.

Joshua

I've read through most the second part of this post again and... may I add something? I just noticed the part where you asked parents to share steps they've taken to pass on a right perspective to daughters. I'm not a parent, but as a young girl I was helped by some cool viewpoints shared with me.
During homeschooling, my mom had my brother and I read a lot of missionary books. These gave me a great perspective on a lot of things -- including looks. At a young age I read about Amy Carmichael and how she had wanted blue eyes. Her mother had blue eyes. But Amy's were brown. It bothered her a lot as a little girl. She prayed that God would change them and was very (very, very) disappointed when He didn't. Later, when she became a missionary and was in a dangerous situation, it was essential that God had, in fact, made her eyes brown because it enabled her to successfully disguise herself as an Indian for one instance -- blue eyes would have given her away in a second!
This lesson has always stuck in my head. God made us the way we are, placed us where we are, and has allowed all that has happened to us for our good. He knows the way we can best serve Him -- and how to best reach who He has for us to reach.
There's a part in a novel I once read where a man comes before God and he wants God to heal him and make him whole. He asks God, "Wouldn't I serve you better if I were whole?" But God responds, "You wouldn't serve me at all if you were whole."
I nearly always think of this when I want to change things or simply complain. I think its really true of many, many of us -- I mean, look at the example of Paul's thorn in the flesh. God didn't take it away for a reason -- even though Paul asked 3 times that it would be removed.

Now, women reading this are probably going, "I'd serve God still if I were prettier!" Well, perhaps you would. But perhaps you would not need Him as much -- perhaps you wouldn't long for beauty and thus know your need to seek out His Beauty, perhaps you'd have friends who like you for your looks and so you would not need to do as kind or important things to be friends with them and thus would not be driven to be a better friend, perhaps you would not see the true beauty in others who have the physical attributes you now dislike so much, perhaps you would witness to others satisfaction in earthly things fitting your preferences rather than satisfaction in God's Will showing that He indeed provides all that we need and that in Him alone is the fullness of Joy no matter what.
Perhaps your need for His Beauty reflected in you would not be attended to with the same measure of persistence and careful detail. Perhaps what is not beautiful to Him on the inside would be covered up by what is beautiful to you on the outside.
Perhaps God knows what is best for you individually and He has created you in such a way and has allowed every circumstance which is in your life to come about in the way it has because He knows what is most conducive to your good and He Loves you so much that He would rather you have what cannot be stolen or fade than what can and will -- even though you may be angry at Him until you understand.
Perhaps the Master is greater than the servant, the Teacher greater than the student, and the Sculptor than the clay.
Perhaps we might submit to His Plan and express His Beauty in the special way He created us to individually -- as He created no other person to in the exact same way.
Perhaps, by submitting to this wonderful and mysterious Plan, we might reach another individual in a way no one else could who is unhappy with something in their life and don't yet know how God alone can help them to overcome it in a way that passes this world's means or hopes or understanding.

But back to you, Josh, I was out shopping today and I began thinking more about this. Many times Christians encourage young girls (or women) to focus on having godly character and thus inner beauty rather than focusing on outward beauty. I, too, think that is more important. But I've come to think that maybe focusing on either -- even on increasing in either -- is quite discouraging since we are often such fallen vessels. I read in a book recently that the best way to have faith is not to focus on having faith, because that often only discourages us, but rather, to focus on the Faithfulness of God. After reading that, I've tried it -- and it's true! I'm thinking that maybe it's the same with beauty and that's why even when we shift our focus from outer-self to inner-self we are still discouraged and feel as if we too often fall short of how we want to be. What do you think?

We have fraternal twin daughters, who are completely different. Both love the Lord greatly, and are in or training for ministry. They also have different personalities, body sizes and types, and expectations about themselves and others. We have always parented around two convictions:

1. God called us to raise adults, not children.

2. God called us to raise them to be uniquely individual members of His body. Raising them up in "the way they should go" means the way THEY UNIQUELY should go.

That said, we taught them to reflect inner beauty by seeking to create a household where "inner" was allowed to be expressed, shared, and affirmed - even when it wasn't all that, well, beautiful. Moreover, we sought to model the same for them - being as transparent as we know how to be about both our successes and our failures.

In adolescence, both of our daughters "kissed dating good-bye." One kissed it "hello" again in, and married my youth pastor in our church. Now they serve alongside me in the church we started five years ago. The other is in seminary and has recently become engaged to a wonderful man of God. They continue to be completely different. But they're best friends, still totally transparent (maybe to a fault), and most importantly, completely in love with Jesus. I don't deserve to be called their dad.

Thank you, Josh for this post.

As a woman who has struggled with body image in the past, it is sad to see how our culture is endlessly perpetuating the cycle of negative body image in women. If mommy is telling her daughter that having a new chest/nose/tummy is what makes her "beautiful", what do you think her daughter is learning from that? Her daughter's learning that she isn't really "beautiful" until she has some work done. She's also learning to look for imperfections in her own body and become very self-critical of her own appearance.

I don't think you are so much saying that all plastic surgery is wrong (although after becoming a mother, I honestly think it is a waste of money), you are more so saying that putting value on the external appearance over inner Godly character is wrong. Unfortunately, this culture emphasizes having perfect body parts over being a beautiful person from the inside. I do agree that the message that this book is telling young girls is very harmful. Mommy isn't any more beautiful just because her tummy looks nicer.

I think its very easy for people, especially women, to unjustly criticize plastic surgery. The point was brought up about dyeing grey hair. How many women who criticize surgery refuse to leave your house until your makeup is put on? I fail to see how you can use make up to cover up your own imperfections, yet look down on someone who used surgery to fix an issue that makeup wouldnt cover. Its all vanity when you get right down to it. However if it corrects a problem that causes self esteem issues, then isnt that a good thing? How far do you take it? What about people who have moles removed, or electrolosys to remove body hair? How about hair plugs? I dont think its "our" culture that has started it..i think were just alot further down the road that started with rouge, then lipstick, then beauty parlors, etc.

Not that any of those are nessecarily bad, there has probably always been traditions or pressure that cause women to meet a different beauty standard.

Most women however would do well to realize that contrary to popular belief, alot of guys actually prefer a natural woman.

Hi everyone, given that this post is days old at this point, I doubt my comments will be seen. Nonetheless, I found Josh's blog randomly and devoured the content in this one. As one of the only guys responding to this post, here's my question: can someone help me, as a male, not love and cherish a beautiful woman simply because she looks great? I'm a young man and have always wrestled with the notion that I should not have a gorgeous woman at my side. As a believer, it's even more difficult to process the image standards I see all around me and not believe it as 'gospel.' To clarify, I feel like all I ever see lately are beautiful young singles and tummy-tucked moms - and I'm very attentive even though I know I shouldn't be. In short, how does a man come to the place where he does not believe the lie that women should look at a certain way? Any answer, even a scathing comment, would be fantastic. Thanks.

You know we're living in Babylon when....

Josh, to be honest with you, there are times where I don't think there's a problem with plastic surgery... I think when the "Babylonian" thinking comes in is when we approach that not thinking "this'll be better for my health..." (few and far between, but its there) but the "its all about me and what'll get me more attention?!"
It's an attitude thing.

Dude: Now I'm hoping you will see MY comment because I've waited a few days to post. To address your question, I would like to offer a scathing comment, but can't seem to think of any right now so will answer another way (unless something comes to mind while I am typing).
I think that the problem you are wrestling with is more common than you think. Every single person I know struggles with, or has struggled with, prejudice. And prejudice (or ungodly, ignorant, or incorrect judgment -- whatever you might label it) is just a symptom (one of many) of not having God's Love and not seeing as He does -- through His Perfect Perspective.
It is actually a very cool, very good thing that you recognized this as a problem that must be fixed and that you admitted this and asked for help. So few of us do that!
My advice to you is simply that you ask God for Him to give you a new heart and eyes to see His Beauty. Once your eyes can see and your heart can love (as He created you to) and you begin to catch a glimpse of His Beauty in His people and His creation and begin to feel His Love and Compassion for people... well, you'll never be the same. And you'll never want to be.
It's just really different when God does this work in changing how you see everyone and everything and replaces your heart... I wish I could explain it, but it's just beyond words.
Also, I want to add that I had questions several years ago that couldn't be answered by the person I asked (who had a good reputation for answering questions on the subject) and a friend gave me the advice I am giving you now (to ask God to change you -- or in my case, it was to ask God to teach me) and I did it and God came through, answering my request, in a way that surprised and astounded me. So, although my advice might sound weird or too simple... He is Faithful.
God bless.

The one word that will describe what I felt when I read this was shock.I would have never thought that this stuff would be in a kid's night time story.I can just imagine a little girl climbing into bed and saying,"Mommie?Could you read me the one about the lady who got the tummy tuck?"It's ridiculous.

Also,plastic surgery in itself isn't a sin.But deep down we all know the reason mommie got her nose job-pride and vanity.Why else would she have done it?

"To make daddy happy" is what most would say.This is vulgar,for the Bible says "Enjoy the wife of your youth" and "Beauty is fleeting," so the dude had a warning.This one I hate the most:"It's my body!I can do what I please with it!" It most certainly is not your body.The Bible says we are a temple of the Lord.You are God's instrument.

I'm a tad late to this post, but I wanted to add that I'm inclined to agree w/ the last post by Morgan. I do not agree as a matter of passing judgement (condemnation)on someones motives to have plastic surgery. It sadness me that we don't see ourselves as 'created' beings, the way we should. God gave us 'that' nose, 'those' lips, etc... Shouldn't we be thankful? Now I can understand in the case of disease, injury, or a birth defect that affects a function(a cleft lip perhaps). Medicine, the practice, is for healing and making whole, not 'renovating'. Braces are even a form of cosmetic surgery.
I would honestly like to know how many people undergo plastic surgery in lieu of disciplining their body. I think the answer would be telling.
As for make-up, even Esther used cosmetics. Cosmetics enhance what's already there, DEPENDING on HOW you use them. Hair dye is obviousally a cover up.
I, personally, decided a long time ago to embrace my signs of aging as God's gift. It's part of how He made us. I treasure my stretchmarks (I was facinated by my mother's as a little girl) as a bage of honor for the children the Lord has sent us (which are 9 in number). I enjoy seeing my hair become more gray as I age (God knows the number of even the gray ones, how exciting is that! and isn't it supposed to be a sign of wisdom?). I love to see the age on my hands because I remember watching my mother's hands as they cared for me and now my hands remind me of her's as I care for my children. I even like my crows feet, they reflect the wear on my face and show those places that get used the most (do I frown a lot or smile? you tell me)! I have CHOSEN to like all this and more, out of THANKFULLNESS.
Sincerely,
Genoise
P.S.(I am 37 and excited to be 38 at the end of the year. Life. What a precious gift!)

Post a comment

Please enter the letter "u" in the field below:

All content on this site is © 2007 Josh Harris